Shanti Menon 2 minute read

3 lies about wind energy, debunked in 30 seconds

Published:

We set the record straight on three common false claims about wind power, so your community can have a fact-based, constructive conversation about energy choices.  


A graphic with a yelling mouth and "Lie #1 They're killing the whales!" on it

The truth: Offshore wind development does not kill whales. 

The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), the agency in charge of protecting whales, has found no evidence linking offshore wind surveys or activity to whale deaths.  

This lie is often spread by groups that sound like they are concerned with environmental protection, such as Protect our Coasts NJ and Green Oceans, but are funded by fossil fuel interests and climate denial think tanks

Ship collisions are the leading cause of death for large whales worldwide, and a warming planet is actually increasing those collisions. Heat-trapping pollution from fossil fuel energy is warming the oceans, shifting whales’ migration routes and feeding patterns, bringing them in closer contact with ships.  

Remote video URL

A graphic with a yelling mouth and "Lie #2 They're killing all the birds!" on it

The truth: Neighborhood cats are 20,000 times more dangerous to birds than wind turbines.  

Wind turbine strikes can happen, but out of an estimated 3.3 billion bird deaths in 2014, less than .025% resulted from turbine collisions, according to analyses by MIT and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. Collisions with glass buildings are far more dangerous to birds, and no one proposes we stop building skyscrapers.  

And compared to cats, which kill billions of birds a year, wind turbines don’t even come close.  Putting a bell on your cat – if they will allow such a thing – is a much better way to help birds. 


A graphic with a yelling mouth and "Lie #3 It's too expensive!" on it

The truth: Wind farms in the U.S. are already reducing electricity bills. 

Land-based wind projects provide one of the lowest-priced energy sources available today. Iowa, where more than 50% of electricity comes from wind, has some of the lowest electricity prices in the country.  

Recent news stories have focused on offshore wind project delays and cancellations, which are being driven by the Trump administration’s actions to block permitting for wind development as well as rising equipment costs. But offshore wind can also bring down electric bills and reduce health costs.  

A recent study by Resources for the Future, a nonpartisan think tank, examined 32 planned U.S. offshore wind projects. They calculated that the benefits of following through on these projects would outweigh costs by 14 to 1. The benefits included preventing 520 premature deaths each year from air pollution and reducing electric bills.  

Learn more 

False claims about wind and other renewable energy sources are pervasive. Get the facts from Environmental Defense Fund.  

The only climate stories you need, straight to your inbox

Want more great environmental stories?

Donate to Environmental Defense Fund and get Solutions, EDF's members-only magazine, delivered to your home.